Additional Premium Calculator
An additional premium is the extra amount you owe after a premium audit. Auditable policies, above all workers’ compensation, are sold on estimated payroll. When the policy period ends, the insurer audits your actual payroll, reprices the policy on the real numbers, and bills the difference. If your payroll grew, that difference is an additional premium. If it shrank, the same math produces a return premium back to you.
The Additional Premium Calculator below does that reconciliation the way an auditor does. Enter the estimated payroll your deposit premium was priced on and the actual payroll the audit found, class code by class code, with the rate per $100 of payroll and your experience modification factor. The tool rebuilds both premiums through the same rating sequence and shows the audit adjustment, so you can check an audit bill before you pay it, or estimate the bill before the auditor arrives.
Class code 1
Class code 2 (optional)
Rating adjustments
Estimates for checking an audit bill. Your carrier rates the audit on the class codes, rates, and mod in your policy and audit statement; use those figures here, not industry averages.
Quick Answer
Key takeaways
- Additional premium = audited premium − deposit premium. Audited premium reprices the same policy on actual payroll; deposit premium is what the estimate produced at policy start.
- Each class code is rated on its own: manual premium = (payroll / 100) × rate per $100, then the experience mod, any premium discount, and any state assessment apply in that order.
- The adjustment runs both ways. Actual payroll below the estimate means a return premium due back to you, not a bill.
- The flat expense constant never changes the additional premium: it is charged once on the deposit premium and once on the audited premium, so it cancels out of the difference.
- Quick Answer
- How to check an audit bill with this calculator
- The audit premium formula, step by step
- Worked examples: owed, refunded, and split by class code
- What the auditor actually counts as payroll
- When an audit bill is fair, and when to push back
- What competing calculators miss
- Frequently asked questions
- Add This Calculator to Your Website
- References
How to check an audit bill with this calculator
Start from the audit statement, not from memory. It lists the class codes the auditor used, the actual payroll in each one, and the rates. Your policy declarations page lists the estimated payroll and rates the deposit premium was built on. Put the two side by side and the calculator does the subtraction an auditor does.
Enter estimated and actual payroll for class code 1. Estimated payroll comes from the policy as issued; actual payroll comes from the audit. If your workforce splits across two class codes, use the class 2 row for the second one instead of blending the rates.
Add the rating adjustments from your policy. The experience modification factor, premium discount, state assessment, and expense constant sit on the declarations page and the audit statement. Leave any that your policy does not have at the pre-filled value: 1.00 for the mod, 0 for the rest. If you want to see how the deposit premium itself was built up from a rate and an exposure base, the base premium calculator works that side of the calculation.
Read the adjustment, not just the audited total. A positive result is an additional premium owed; a negative result is shown as a return premium due to you. Compare the figure with the audit bill. A small gap is usually rounding or a fee billed separately; a large gap means a class code, a rate, or a payroll figure differs, and that is worth a phone call before you pay.
The audit premium formula, step by step
Workers' compensation and other auditable policies are priced in two passes over the same formula, which is why the IRMI definition of additional premium describes it as the premium generated when the audited exposure exceeds what the policy was issued on. The rating bureaus, led by the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI), set the sequence: rate each class code per $100 of payroll, apply the experience modification factor, then the policy's discount, assessments, and expense constant.
Modified premium: total manual premium × experience modification factor.
Final premium: modified premium × (1 − premium discount %) × (1 + state assessment %) + expense constant.
Additional premium: audited final premium − deposit final premium. Negative means a return premium is due to you.
Two points in that sequence cause most of the confusion on real audit bills. First, the experience mod multiplies the whole manual premium, so a payroll increase found at audit costs more when your mod is above 1.00 and less when it is below: the mod is set by your claims history under the IRMI description of experience rating, and it does not change because of the audit itself. Second, general liability audits often rate on a different exposure base, commonly gross sales per $1,000 rather than payroll per $100. The subtraction works identically; only the unit changes. This calculator is built for payroll-rated policies, which covers workers' compensation and payroll-rated liability classes.
Worked examples: owed, refunded, and split by class code
The first example below is the pre-filled one, and it is a published audit example, not an invented round number: a rate of $17.00 per $100 on $147,000 of projected payroll produces a $24,990 deposit premium, and the audit at $163,000 reprices it to $27,710. The other rows are calculated with the same tool logic and checked by hand:
| Case | Inputs | Deposit premium | Audited premium | Adjustment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Payroll grew (pre-filled) | Estimated $147,000, actual $163,000, rate $17.00, mod 1.00 | $24,990.00 | $27,710.00 | $2,720.00 owed |
| Payroll shrank | Estimated $163,000, actual $147,000, rate $17.00, mod 1.00 | $27,710.00 | $24,990.00 | $2,720.00 returned |
| Two class codes | Clerical $25,000 at $0.28; field staff estimated $100,000, actual $110,000, at $1.75; mod 1.00 | $1,820.00 | $1,995.00 | $175.00 owed |
| Mod, discount, assessment | Estimated $100,000, actual $120,000, rate $5.00, mod 1.10, discount 10%, assessment 5%, expense constant $200 | $5,397.50 | $6,437.00 | $1,039.50 owed |
The two-class example shows why auditors refuse to blend rates. The clerical payroll at $0.28 per $100 contributes $70.00 on both passes because it did not change. The whole $175.00 adjustment comes from the field staff: $10,000 of extra payroll at $1.75 per $100. If that payroll had been misclassified as clerical for the whole year, the same $10,000 would have been billed at $0.28, and the correction at audit would be the difference between the two rates on the full amount, not just on the growth.
What the auditor actually counts as payroll
Most audit disputes are not about the formula. They are about which dollars the auditor put into actual payroll. Auditors work from payroll registers, tax filings such as Form 941, and job descriptions, and the figure they call remuneration is wider than take-home pay: wages, salaries, bonuses, commissions, and holiday and vacation pay all count. Three adjustments decide most bills.
Overtime is the first. In most states only the straight-time portion counts: pay at time and a half is split, and the extra half is excluded from premium payroll. If your records do not separate the overtime premium portion, auditors may count the whole amount, and the fix is better records, not an argument. Uninsured subcontractors are the second. Payments to subcontractors without a valid certificate of insurance are commonly added to your payroll at the rate for the work they did, which is how a paperwork gap turns into a four-figure audit bill. Officers and owners are the third: included officers are rated at a payroll amount bounded by state minimums and maximums, so the figure on the audit may not match the salary actually paid. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners consumer resources explain how to take a billing dispute to your state department of insurance if the auditor's payroll figure still does not stand up.
None of that requires a second tool. Adjust the actual payroll figure to the audited definition (strip the overtime premium portion, add uninsured subcontractor labor, apply the officer limits from your audit statement) and run this calculator again. What changes is the input, not the math.
When an audit bill is fair, and when to push back
An audit bill is fair when it is just your real payroll run through your real rates. Payroll genuinely grew during the year, the class codes match the work, and the mod and rates match the policy: that bill is the premium the coverage actually cost, and the Insurance Information Institute guide to what sets an insurance price makes the same point for premium generally, that price follows exposure and risk. Push back when the inputs are wrong, because the formula faithfully multiplies wrong inputs too.
Usually fair
- Payroll grew because you hired, raised wages, or worked more overtime, and the audit payroll ties to your tax filings.
- Each class code matches the work actually done, and the rates and mod match the policy as issued.
- The bill equals audited premium minus deposit premium, with the expense constant charged once, not twice.
- A return premium is credited in full when payroll fell, on the same rating sequence as the original bill.
Worth disputing
- Field payroll rated at a higher class code than the duties justify, or clerical staff swept into a field code.
- Overtime counted in full, with the premium portion never stripped out.
- Subcontractor payments charged even though you hold valid certificates of insurance for them.
- A mod or rate on the audit statement that differs from the policy. That is an input error, and it reprices every dollar.
Keep the dispute narrow and documented: name the class code, the payroll figure, or the certificate in question, and send the record that supports your version. Audits can generally be revisited while the policy period is still within the carrier's dispute window, and a corrected audit replaces the original bill. This is also a different charge from a mid-term endorsement price: adding coverage mid-term creates its own additional premium, and stretching that charge to a full-year figure is what the annualized endorsement premium calculator is for. Audit additional premium needs no annualizing; it is already a full policy period reconciled.
What competing calculators miss
We checked the top-ranking pages for this search before rebuilding this one. The striking result is that almost nobody offers a working additional premium calculator for audits at all. The pages that rank are premium estimators and audit guides, and each stops before the reconciliation that produces the bill.
Winning move 1: the reconciliation itself, not another estimate. Workers' compensation estimators such as the ones at MyInsuranceCalc and WorkCompOne price a single premium from a single payroll figure. That is the deposit premium half of the story. An audit bill exists because there are two payroll figures, estimated and actual, and nobody ranking for this search subtracts one premium from the other. This tool does exactly that subtraction and labels the result owed or due back.
Winning move 2: two class codes, rated separately. Estimators that blend a workforce into one rate hide the most expensive audit finding there is: payroll sitting in the wrong class code. Rating clerical and field payroll on separate rows, at $0.28 and $1.75 in the worked example, shows both the growth adjustment and the misclassification exposure in one run.
Winning move 3: the full rating sequence, in the open. Audit guides describe the mod in prose and stop. Here the experience mod, premium discount, state assessment, and expense constant are inputs, applied in the bureau sequence to both premiums, so you can point at the exact line where your audit statement and this calculation diverge. The insurer-side view of the same machinery, expected losses against actual losses, is what the actuarial premium calculator covers.
One gap no competitor fills either: none of the ranking pages warns that a negative adjustment is money back, and employers routinely leave return premiums unclaimed after a slow year. This page treats the return premium as a headline result, because on the pre-filled rates a payroll drop of $16,000 is worth $2,720 back.
Frequently asked questions
The difference between the audited premium and the deposit premium. The policy was priced on estimated payroll; the audit reprices it on actual payroll, and if actual payroll was higher, the difference is billed as additional premium.
For each class code, divide actual payroll by 100 and multiply by the rate per $100. Add the class codes together, multiply by the experience modification factor, apply any premium discount and state assessment, and add the expense constant.
The adjustment runs the other way: audited premium comes out below the deposit premium you already paid, and the difference is a return premium the insurer owes you. This calculator shows it as a return premium due, not a negative bill.
Because it is a flat charge added once to the deposit premium and once to the audited premium. When the two are subtracted, the same amount appears on both sides and cancels out. It raises both totals, never the difference between them.
Remuneration: wages, salaries, bonuses, commissions, and paid holiday and vacation time. In most states only the straight-time portion of overtime counts, payments to uninsured subcontractors can be added, and included officers are rated between state minimum and maximum payroll limits.
Yes. Check the class codes against actual job duties, the audit payroll against your tax filings, and the rates and mod against the policy. Send the carrier the records that support your figures; a corrected audit replaces the original bill.
Add This Calculator to Your Website
References
- IRMI (International Risk Management Institute), Insurance Definitions, "Additional Premium" - the extra premium charged when a policy change increases coverage or exposure after issue. IRMI: Additional Premium. Accessed October 2026.
- IRMI (International Risk Management Institute), Insurance Definitions, "Experience Rating" - how a policyholder claims history produces adjustment factors above or below 1.00 at renewal. IRMI: Experience Rating. Accessed October 2026.
- National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI), "ABCs of Experience Rating" - manual premium per $100 of payroll by classification, summed, then multiplied by the modification factor to reach modified premium (Exhibits D and E). NCCI: ABCs of Experience Rating. Accessed October 2026.
- Workers' Compensation Consultants, "How can my insurance company bill me for more premium after my workers compensation policy has expired?" - the published worked example behind this page's pre-filled values: $17.00 rate, $147,000 projected payroll, $24,990 deposit premium, $163,000 audited payroll, $27,710 audited premium, $2,720 additional premium. Workers' Compensation Consultants: Audit Additional Premium Example. Accessed October 2026.
- Insurance Information Institute, "What determines the price of an auto insurance policy?" - the coverage amounts, risk factors, and deductible choices that set a premium. III: What Determines the Price of an Auto Insurance Policy. Accessed October 2026.
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners, "Consumer Insurance Resources" - state regulator guidance on policy changes, endorsements, and where to verify billing rules. NAIC: Consumer Insurance Resources. Accessed October 2026.
